PME means professional military education. The Classroom version is also available for high school.
In a business class working a retailer's case, the teacher gives every student the same AI-drafted recommendation to review, then sign or revise. The case asks: should the retailer's support chatbot answer refund questions? The class allows AI, and each copy is tagged "drafted with AI", so identical copies are expected. Two students read it closely and sign it as written. What can happen next is responsibility laundering: the model's recommendation makes responsibility feel shared, or easier to defend. The retailer, the students, their AI, the chatbot and the 97% are constructed. Related case: Moffatt v. Air Canada (2024), in which a tribunal held an airline responsible for what its chatbot told a customer.
An animated figure, "Responsibility laundering", failure mode 7 of 7. It opens on its name, which then stays in the top-left corner. Two red dots stand for two students working a retailer's case for a business class, with AI use allowed and disclosed, and an example task: should the support chatbot answer refund questions? The teacher gives both the same AI draft to review, then sign or revise, shown in grey, the figure's mark for words the AI wrote: "The analysis estimates 97% accuracy. It is recommended that the chatbot go live." The draft divides into two copies, one for each student, both marked "drafted with AI". Both students read it closely, at the same pace, and agree. The first signs in red. The second first writes a red note in a row labelled "their own note · not handed in": "Rests on last quarter's questions. Recent: similar." Then they sign. While the teacher asks, the note row dims under "The teacher doesn’t see this", and a frame labelled "What the teacher sees" goes round the two identical copies. The teacher asks each student: "If it misleads a customer, who made this call?" Both say, "I did. I signed it." Then: "Why did you rely on it?" The first says, "The analysis estimated 97%. It seemed solid." The second says, "It rests on last quarter's questions. Recent ones matched, so I accepted it. I didn't try unusual requests." Then, one change at a time: the note returns; "The analysis" is outlined in the first student's second answer and on their copy; the first student's dot parts into two halves, and one half travels up to "The analysis estimates" and becomes a hollow dashed grey ring, keyed "reason handed to the AI", where it stays; a red bracket marks the second student's second answer, their own reason, and their dot stays whole. Two navy weights labelled "Answerable" come down, one on each copy, past the AI's sentences, and rest on each student's dot at the signature. As the first weight comes to rest, the first student's dot is whole again; the grey ring stays. The figure ends on the name and its definition, "The model’s recommendation makes responsibility feel shared, or easier to defend.", above the teacher’s check, with the source line: "Related case: Moffatt v. Air Canada (2024): a company was held responsible for what its chatbot told a customer." Each beat is listed below with what is on screen.
0Responsibility laundering · Failure mode 7 of 7
On screen: the name, "Responsibility laundering", appears large over the stage with "Failure mode 7 of 7" above it, then moves into the top-left corner, where it stays.
1Two students, one task.
On screen: a task card appears: "Example task: Should the support chatbot answer refund questions?" Two red dots appear, labelled First student and Second student.
2The teacher gives both the same AI draft to review.
On screen: both dots pulse. A sheet fills at the centre in grey on a beige band: "The analysis estimates 97% accuracy." "It is recommended that the chatbot go live." It divides into two identical copies, labelled "First student's copy, drafted with AI" and "Second student's copy, drafted with AI".
3Both students read it closely and agree.
On screen: a key below names the beige band "Written by AI". Both dots read along every line of their copies, at the same pace and at the same time. Nothing changes.
4The first student signs. The second notes what the estimate rests on, then signs.
On screen: the first dot signs in red, and the key adds "A student's decision" in red. The second dot moves to a row labelled "Their own note · not handed in" and writes a red note: "Rests on last quarter's questions. Recent: similar." The first student has no note. Then the second dot signs. The note stays.
5The teacher asks each student.
On screen: the note row dims under "The teacher doesn’t see this", and a frame labelled "What the teacher sees" goes round the two copies. "1. If it misleads a customer, who made this call?" Both students say, "I did. I signed it."
6The teacher asks why.
On screen: "2. Why did you rely on it?" The first student says, "The analysis estimated 97%. It seemed solid." The second says, "It rests on last quarter's questions. Recent ones matched, so I accepted it. I didn't try unusual requests."
7The first gives the AI's reason. The second gives their own.
On screen: one change at a time. The frame goes and the note returns. "The analysis" is outlined in the first student's second answer and on their copy. The first student's dot parts into two halves. One half travels slowly up the copy's edge to "The analysis estimates", trailing a dashed line, and becomes a hollow dashed grey ring, keyed "Reason handed to the AI". It stays. Then a red bracket marks the second student's second answer, their own reason; their dot stays whole.
8Suppose it proves wrong. The AI can't answer for it. Both students will.
On screen: a navy weight labelled "Answerable" comes down the first copy's edge, past the AI's sentences and the grey ring, and comes to rest at the signature. As it does, the first student's dot is whole again; the grey ring stays. A second weight does the same on the second copy.
9Teacher’s check: Who owns the recommendation if it proves wrong? Name one way it could prove wrong. Ask why they relied on it.
On screen: the questions appear under the picture at the same size. Both copies, the note, all four answers, the grey ring and both weights stay in view, with the source line: "Related case: Moffatt v. Air Canada (2024): a company was held responsible for what its chatbot told a customer."
Teacher’s check
Who owns the recommendation if it proves wrong?
Name one way it could prove wrong. Ask why they relied on it.
Both students signed the same recommendation. If it proves wrong, both answer for it to the teacher, for the work they submit, and the AI can't. Asked who made the call, both say they did. Asked why they relied on the AI's estimate, the first student repeats the analysis: 97%, and it seemed solid. The second says what the estimate rested on, why they accepted it, and what they didn't try: unusual requests, like a refund asked for late. Both answer for the call. Only the second can say what it rested on. That answer is hard to give without asking the question before signing, and the second student's note shows they did. Whether relying on the estimate was justified is a separate check, covered by uncalibrated reliance.
A related case
Moffatt v. Air Canada (2024) is a related case at the scale of an organization: who answers for an AI's answer? The airline argued, in effect, that its chatbot was responsible for its own answers, and a tribunal held the company responsible. It differs from the figure: the airline disowned its chatbot's answer, and the first student owns the call and hands off only the reason. The case also says nothing about students signing a recommendation for a class.
In November 2022, after a death in their family, a customer asked the chatbot on Air Canada's website about bereavement fares, the lower fares some airlines offer for travel after a death in the family. The chatbot told them: "If you need to travel immediately or have already travelled and would like to submit your ticket for a reduced bereavement rate, kindly do so within 90 days of the date your ticket was issued…" (para. 15). Its answer linked to the airline's bereavement page (para. 16), which, the decision notes, said the policy does not apply to requests made after travel is complete (para. 17). The customer later learned from Air Canada employees that it "did not permit retroactive applications" (para. 2): claims made after the trip.
The tribunal summed up the airline's position: "Air Canada argues it cannot be held liable for information provided by one of its agents, servants, or representatives – including a chatbot." It went on: "In effect, Air Canada suggests the chatbot is a separate legal entity that is responsible for its own actions. This is a remarkable submission." (para. 27)
The decision goes on: "It should be obvious to Air Canada that it is responsible for all the information on its website. It makes no difference whether the information comes from a static page or a chatbot." (para. 27) It found that Air Canada "did not take reasonable care to ensure its chatbot was accurate", and noted that the airline "does not explain why customers should have to double-check information found in one part of its website on another part of its website" (para. 28).
The order was against the airline: it was to pay $812.02, including $650.88 in damages (para. 44). In the figure, "answer for it" means to the teacher, for the work they submit. The figure makes no claim about anyone's personal legal liability.
The record has limits. It is one decision of British Columbia's Civil Resolution Tribunal, which decides small claims (para. 7). It doesn't say how the chatbot worked or how it was tested: the decision notes that Air Canada "did not provide any information about the nature of its chatbot" (para. 14).
Source: Moffatt v. Air Canada, 2024 BCCRT 149, Civil Resolution Tribunal, February 14, 2024. Every quote is from the decision, with its paragraph number. The retailer, the students, their AI, the chatbot, the 97% and the answers are constructed.
From the original PME essay
Responsibility laundering is the final danger. A recommendation becomes easier to defend because the model generated it, or easier to soften because the model's language distributes agency. The analysis lands with the apparent weight of objectivity. But AI does not become accountable for the recommendation. The human remains responsible for the final judgment. When the recommendation proves wrong, shaped by assumptions no one examined and optimizing toward a target no one explicitly chose, the question of who chose the frame does not have a satisfying answer.
The failure mode and the teacher’s check come from an essay about judgment in military education. This page shows the same move in a business class working a retailer's case.